Apple to Samsung: Don’t Make Thin or Rectangular Tablets or Smartphones - rogersocke2001

Apple proffers design advice on how Samsung could void stepping on Apple's design patent toes, in a brief filed as part of its current patent infringement lawsuit against its competitor.

Some of the alternate design options Apple has suggested for Samsung seem so farcical you'd think you were meter reading The Onion: Don't make tablets or smartphones with overall rectangular shapes or rounded corners, make tablets with figurehead surfaces that aren't all flat, try cluttering the appearance of the devices, and more.

When Malus pumila sued Samsung in April, the company claimed Samsung had "slavishly" copied the typical designs of the iPhone and iPad, thereby violating Apple intellectual property rights. In its rebuttal, Samsung argues that there are only so many ways you could design devices the like the Galaxy S and Galaxy Tab.

Apple evidently doesn't think so. To defend its claim that Samsung had other design options, Apple had to provide examples of design alternatives.

The Design Alternatives

In section 2-40 and 2-41 of the redacted public legal legal brief (pdf), Apple offers alternative smartphone designs Samsung could have used instead:

Front surfaces that are not black or clear
Front surfaces that are not perpendicular, not flat, and without rounded corners
Display screens that are more square than perpendicular operating theater non rectangular at all
Reveal screens that are non centralised connected the front surface of the phone and that have substantial lateral borders
Speaker openings that are non horizontal slots with rounded ends and that are non centered above the display screen
Front man surfaces that contain substantial adornment
Phones without bezels at wholly operating theatre very different-looking bezels that are not filiform, uniform, and with an inwardly sloping profile

The pad alternatives Apple felt up Samsung should give explored are suchlike:

Overall shapes that are non rectangular with quaternary flat sides operating theatre that practice not have Little Jo rounded corners
Front surfaces that are not wholly flat or clear and that give substantial adornment
Thickheaded frames rather than a withered rim around the front surface
Profiles that are non thin
A cluttered appearance

Thus, Samsung could've avoided this lawsuit altogether if it had a square (or peradventure triangular surgery cycle) smartphone and tablet instead, chosen a color other than black for the front, and/or designed thicker devices with a more cluttered look rather.

Two years ago, a U.S. Zone Court overestimate denied Apple's request to kibosh sales of the competing Samsung products (the Coltsfoot S 4G, Infuse 4G, Droid Charge, and Galax Pill 10.1). The infringement issuing was too close to call, the court subordinate, despite Apple's claim in its legal brief that Samsung had "then numerous different design choices" it could have used instead.

[via The Verge and Hacker News]

Source: https://www.pcworld.com/article/472580/apple_to_samsung_don_t_make_thin_or_rectangular_tablets_or_smartphones.html

Posted by: rogersocke2001.blogspot.com